The NCIS franchise expanded last year to include the prequel, Origins, and in doing so, it began exploring the pasts of several characters we’d already met in the present. The series follows Leroy Jethro Gibbs (Austin Stowell in the prequel, Mark Harmon on the mothership), as a probie on Mike Franks’ (Kyle Schmid, Muse Watson) team, and Vera Strickland (Diany Rodriguez, Roma Maffia) works out of the same office. In the recent crossover, Bobby Moynihan and Ely Henry played older versions of Woody and Phil, so we know they live to 2025. There’s a mystery surrounding Lala (Mariel Molino), so we don’t expect to see her in the present. But what about Randy? We asked Caleb Foote for his theory about his character.

“This is something that my parents can’t let go either,” Foote tells TV Insider with a laugh. “My parents are always just trying to pitch ideas to have an old Randy come back in the mothership.”

Originally published on tvinsider.com, part of the BLOX Digital Content Exchange.