Lauren Jauregui‘s shocking elimination from Dancing With the Stars has fans of the show begging for the return of a since-removed rule.

The Fifth Harmony singer and her partner, Brandon Armstrong, were the third couple of the season to be sent home on Tuesday, September 30. After the episode, viewers took to social media to demand that the ABC series reinstate the judges’ save rule, which allowed the show’s panel of judges to choose which of the lower-ranking couples would leave the competition and which would stay to dance another week.

Originally published on tvinsider.com, part of the BLOX Digital Content Exchange.