New ‘flat-faced’ dog breeds identified as at risk of deadly condition

Scientists have found a dozen further breeds threatened by Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS) - including the Pekingese, Shih Tzu, Boston Terrier and Cavalier King Charles Spaniel.

Pugs, French Bulldogs and Bulldogs were already known to be at risk.

Dogs who are overweight or who have narrowed nostrils or a wider, shorter head shape are more likely to suffer from BOAS, according to new research from the Cambridge Veterinary School.

In some breeds, the research team found that shorter tails and thicker necks are an additional risk factor.

The study, published in the journal PLOS One, found that BOAS varies considerably, in prevalence and severity, between flat-faced dog breeds and also within each breed.

In BOAS, lesions within the upper respiratory tract result in narrowing of the airway, which often leads to noisy breathing but can also reduce a dog’s ability to exercise, sleep and cope with heat or stress.

Study co-leader Dr. Fran Tomlinson said: “BOAS exists on a spectrum.

"Some dogs are only mildly affected, but for those at the more severe end, it can significantly reduce quality of life and become a serious welfare issue.

“While surgery, weight management and other interventions can help affected dogs to some degree, BOAS is hereditary, and there is still much to learn about how we can reduce the risk in future generations.”

While previous research into BOAS has focused on the three most popular ‘flat-faced’ dog breeds in the UK - the French Bulldog, the Pug and Bulldog – this study investigated a further 14 breeds.

These are the Affenpinscher, Boston Terrier, Boxer, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Chihuahua, Dogue de Bordeaux, Griffon Bruxellois, Japanese Chin, King Charles Spaniel, Maltese, Pekingese, Pomeranian, Shih Tzu and the Staffordshire Bull Terrier.

The University of Cambridge-led study, which involved nearly 900 dogs, found that 12 out of the 14 breeds studied had some detectable level of breathing abnormality.

The research team identified two breeds at high risk of BOAS, with 89% of Pekingese and 82% of Japanese Chin found to be affected: rates comparable with Pugs, French Bulldogs and Bulldogs.

Five breeds were found to be at moderate risk of BOAS – the King Charles Spaniel, Shih Tzu, Griffon Bruxellois, Boston Terrier, and the Dogue de Bordeaux – with half to three-quarters of the dogs studied being affected.

Staffordshire Bull Terriers, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Chihuahua, Boxer, and Affenpinscher were found to be at "mild" risk, with only half of dogs having some degree of noisy breathing and only a few animals with clinically significant disease.

None of the Pomeranian or Maltese dogs studied were found to be clinically affected.

The researchers assessed the dogs during individual appointments at the Queen’s Veterinary School Hospital in Cambridge, at dog shows and at breed-specific health testing days.

The UK Kennel Club and the University of Cambridge run a Respiratory Function Grading Scheme to assess French Bulldogs, Bulldogs and Pugs, which is used in many countries around the world.

The research team adapted the assessment to enable them to study the 14 additional breeds.

The team assessed the dogs’ breathing before and after a 3-minute exercise test, grading any upper respiratory noises and signs of difficulty or discomfort.

Dogs that completed the exercise test with no breathing discomfort or respiratory noise detected were classified as unaffected, while dogs that displayed any upper airway noises were classified from mild to severe BOAS.

The research team explained that ‘brachycephalic’ dog breeds are generally associated with shortened muzzles, and are described as being ‘flat-faced’ or as having ‘facial hypoplasia’.

But they pointed out that dogs which have a relatively wide skull in comparison to its length, such as the Staffordshire Bull Terrier, can also be considered brachycephalic.

The team found that dogs with wider shorter head shapes – those with a lower craniofacial ratio – were more likely to have BOAS.

Dr. David Sargan said: “Our findings show that the relationship between relative muzzle length and BOAS risk is more complex than is commonly assumed.

“The King Charles Spaniel, also known as the English Toy Spaniel in the US, is an extremely flat-faced breed so you might expect to find it in a higher risk group.

"However, 40% of the animals we assessed were unaffected by BOAS.”

He said nostril ‘stenosis’ - or narrowing - had previously been reported as a key risk factor for BOAS.

The new study provided more evidence with the researchers finding that prevalence of the problem varied "substantially" between different breeds and was significantly associated with BOAS risk.

The two breeds found to be high risk for BOAS, the Pekingese and Japanese Chin, had high rates of nostril narrowing.

Only around 6% and 18% of dogs respectively had open nostrils.

The Griffon Bruxellois and the Boston Terrier, breeds at moderate risk of BOAS, were also more likely to have restricted nostrils than the other breeds.

In both the Shih Tzu and Staffordshire Bull Terrier breeds, the researchers found that shorter tails were associated with an increased risk of BOAS.

For the Staffordshire Bull Terriers, those with longer tails were around 30% less likely to have BOAS, and affected dogs had tails 1.5 centimeters (0.6 inches) shorter on average.

In the Boston Terrier and Staffordshire Bull Terrier breeds, the reserchers found that dogs with proportionately thicker necks were more likely to be affected.

Neck girth ratio has previously been noted to be a significant factor in the risk of BOAS in Bulldogs and French Bulldogs.

Study co-leader Dr. Jane Ladlow said: “Considering the close genetic relationship between Staffordshire Bull Terriers, Boston Terriers and the bulldogs, it isn’t surprising that they share this link between neck thickness and BOAS.”

In the Chihuahua and King Charles Spaniel breeds, the researchers found that dogs with relatively longer bodies with a shorter height were more likely to affected by BOAS.

The researchers found that being overweight was a significant risk factor for the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, the Shih Tzu and the Affenpinscher.

Dr. Ladlow said: “Weight loss could be used as a management tool to reduce the risk of BOAS in these three breeds, as it is in the Pug."

The researchers hope the study will lead to more ‘flat-faced’ dogs being tested.

Dr. Ladlow said: “Being aware of risk factors can be useful for both breeders and prospective owners in selecting dogs which are less likely to be affected by BOAS.

"Knowledge of these risk factors can also help to inform judges in deciding which features are detrimental to health so that factors associated with BOAS are not rewarded in the show ring, particularly as winning dogs can become popular sires.”

Dr. Tomlinson added: “Each individual breed has its own risk profile for BOAS and different factors affecting this.

“Our findings support a breed-specific approach when tackling the reduction of this disease on a population level.”