THE DALLES — Prosecutors failed to convince jurors beyond a reasonable doubt that Dan Watson murdered Amanda Harman more than three years ago, a 12-person panel in Wasco County Circuit Court decided on Nov. 10, so the case will be heard again.
Then 35 years old, Harman was found dead in her Cherry Heights home with multiple stab wounds on March 17, 2023. Police arrested Watson that June and subsequently charged him with murder in the second degree, burglary in the first degree, unlawful use of a weapon and unauthorized use of a vehicle — all felonies.
The state called its first of 41 potential witnesses on Oct. 28 of this year. Guilty verdicts in felony cases require unanimous agreement by the jury, however, and at least 10 jurors must concur on any not-guilty verdict.
The jury was hung on all four charges.
A hearing to schedule another trial on the same charges is set for Dec. 4.
The Wasco County District Attorney’s Office and Watson’s legal counsel both declined to comment on the outcome.
Court records submitted prior to the trial show that prosecutors were heavily relying on DNA evidence to connect Watson to the crime. Watson’s blood was found on the Kubota RTV that police believe he used to flee Harman’s home, and his profile was the most dominant one found underneath Harman’s fingernails. He also blamed Harman and her partner, Colt Brace, for an earlier divorce.
On the other side, Watson’s attorneys claim that police reviewed but never saved security footage that placed Watson at his home the night Harman was killed. They also pointed to another suspect who lived nearby, has a history of drug use, and made multiple suspicious statements following this incident.
He reportedly told an acquaintance that “they’re going to try and pin this on me.” Additionally, when asked if he had a knife or screwdriver with Harman’s blood on it, he replied: “Well, I might.”
•••
Columbia Gorge News was unable to obtain a recording of the decision by press deadline. The online version of this story will be updated as more information becomes available.
Commented