(The Center Square) — Advocates debated whether to expand the number of justices on the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday.
The Cato Institute hosted a discussion between Stephen Feldman, a law professor at the University of Wyoming and Roman Buhler, national director of the Madison Coalition, about proposals to expand membership on the court.
Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., who is expected to be elected Speaker of the House, called for changes to the high court in a letter to his Democratic colleagues, but did not explicitly advocate for expansion of the high court.
"We must root out corrupt price gouging, clean up the mess at the Supreme Court and ban Members of Congress from trading stocks," Jeffries wrote.
In September, Congress failed to pass a measure to cap the number of justices on the high court at nine by a vote of 212-206, according to the U.S. House clerk.
Feldman said Congress could allow for the high court to be composed of 13 justices in order to balance the political scales. He argued that the court’s interpretation of case law will always be political, regardless of how many justices are on the bench.
“Constitutional interpretation and judicial decision-making are always partly political,” Feldman said. “Politics is always intertwined with interpretation.”
However, Buhler advocated for a constitutional amendment that would cap the number of justices on the high court at nine. He pointed out that a similar amendment was first introduced by Rep. Collin Peterson, D-Minn., in 2020.
“How can you have a democracy when the referee that's supposed to decide whether the rules are being enforced is controlled by the ruling party? We see around the country that every would-be dictator tries to get control of the court by adding justices, by throwing them off,” Buhler said. “We don't want to bring that here.”
Buhler argued that partisanship should not be allowed to influence outcomes on the court. He said recent calls for expanding the court come after critical policy upheaval on abortion, voting rights and energy.
Feldman said expanding the court from nine to 13 justices will bring about greater bipartisanship in Congress. He argued the proposal keeps the justices focused on apolitical decision-making.
“This court is not an apolitical court,” Feldman said. “This court is extremely conservative, and it showed that over and over again.”
Buhler said adding justices to the court would further influence political outcomes. He said justices would be appointed to the court with the specific goal of overturning legal precedent and achieving certain outcomes.
He said the decision to overturn Roe v. Wade left Congress with the power to change laws surrounding abortion policy, not the courts.
“People who want to see reform can do it by passing laws without having to undermine the independence of the court that protects democracy from authoritarians,” Buhler said.
Feldman argued that the court’s most significant decisions have aligned with President Donald Trump’s policy priorities. He pointed to the court’s decision to overturn 90-year-old precedent that prevented presidents from firing Federal Trade Commission members in Trump v. Slaughter.
“There are many instances where this court just does not seem to respect precedents that have been on the books for years,” Feldman said. “It doesn't mean they can never be overruled, but there's an incredible pattern of disdain for the justices of the past.”
Buhler argued that overturning precedent should not be a marker of whether the court is motivated by politics. He pointed to the court’s decision to overturn Plessy v. Ferguson, a case that legalized segregation.
“It was one of the great moments in American history when the Supreme Court, in Brown versus Board of Education, overturned Plessy,” Buhler said. “Just because the Supreme Court has done something in the past doesn't make it right.”

Commented